Clash of Civilizations

Free Speech vs. “Muslim Rage”.

The explosion of controversy surrounding the “Innocence of Muslims” film and the supposedly “senseless” violence that ensued in Libya and elsewhere after its reception, point to a significant hole in the American worldview. That is, many Americans still cannot comprehend that their nation’s values are not universal, nor even entirely logically sound.

In an insightful article, literary critic Stanley Fish evokes how many Americans cannot imagine that others have values which conflict with the catechism of Free Speech, “the assumption is that if they (the rest of the world) had heard of it (the first amendment) and read it and gotten its message, they would have understood that you don’t target or attack people because of what they have written; you don’t respond to words, however harsh and wounding you take them to be, as if they were physical blows.” But the issue here is based on a clash of two civilizations, one in which our concept of religion is privatized and compartmentalized (if not secularized), and the other where, as Fish goes on to say, “religion is not an internal, privatized matter safe from the world’s surfaces, but an overriding imperative that the world’s surfaces should reflect”. In the context of this other civilization, “a verbal or pictorial assault on their religion will not be received as an external and ephemeral annoyance, as a ‘mere’ representation; it will be received as a wounding to the heart, as a blow, and as a blow that is properly met by blows in return. No ‘sticks and stones will break my bones but names will never hurt me’ for them.”

There appears to be radically different worldviews coming into collision here, but in fact, we are as equally defensive of our First Amendment ideals as those in Libya are of their religious convictions. Fish ends his piece with a provocative comparison between belief in “Free Speech” and belief in “God” or “Truth”. For many of us in the West, Free Speech is a value imbued with religious fervor – it is an abstract and invisibly entity that we cathect with meaning and “believe” in – this is why “secular humanism” is called out by some as a “religion” in itself.

The paradox of Free Speech is that we tolerate intolerance. We tolerate those explicitly blasphemous scenes in “Innocence of Muslims” all in the name of Free Speech, but yet we are wholly intolerant of their intolerance – we think the calm rationale of Free Speech sets us apart from the inflamed “sensitivity” of the “Muslim World.” This is where we expose ourselves as hypocrites. We point out “Muslim Rage,” while we too are intolerant of having our most foundational beliefs denounced …and perhaps we are even more “sensitive”, for those in Libya are reacting to slander, while we react with outrage when our worldview is simply not accepted by people half way across the world. This whole controversy reveals the that the West is somehow still incapable of seeing over the rims of its own worldview. This near-sightedness may be what is most “senseless” here.

Read more on Adbusters.org

Como fazer dinheiro de verdade com Mídias Sociais?

SMW

Antes que alguém atire a primeira pedra, este não é um post sobre as longas discussões acerca da monetização de blogs e afins.

Um dos eventos que tive o prazer de estar ontem era, na promessa, um workshop de pitch. Traduzindo: seria um momento para receber alguma mentoria gratuita de três investidores-anjo para apresentar idéias de empresas revolucionárias para outros investidores em alguns dias. E enfim fazer muito dinheiro com alguma nova traquitana de Mídias Sociais.

Como já comentei em alguns Braincasts, eu estou na mesma batalha: modelando meu próprio negócio, que não é uma traquitana, e buscando acertar um ou outro ponto que ainda não está bem esclarecido sobre como trabalhar, ganhar dinheiro, ficar rico, enfim.

O que encontrei, definitivamente, valeu o dia.

bsceene

A empresa que patrocinou este evento, a Bsceene, é uma espécie de produtora digital. para artistas que precisam da aporte tecnológico para expor sua arte na Internet. Por também ser, por assim dizer, uma startup, trouxe para um papo de 2 horas (que passaram como 15 minutos) três investidores locais que estão ajudando a levantar Chicago (e provavelmente a própria Bsceene). Tony Wilkins (investidor-anjo e mentor da Excelerate – aceleradora já comentada por aqui), Drew Barrett (consultor de negócios internacionais, incluindo alguns para turismo no Brasil) e Bruce Montgomery (mantém negócios em TI e foi apresentado como “o homem dos contatos em Chicago”).

O papo foi além do “o que esperamos que você apresente quando vier com sua idéia para um pitch” e passou por algumas boas histórias (ninguém ali aparentava ter menos de 50 anos) sobre investimentos, empresas promissoras que em nada deram, empresas que venceram, mercados interessantes que não estão tão na moda. Falaram também sobre o relacionamento entre investidores e empresas e foram extremamente solícitos ao serem abordados ao final do evento por diversos sonhadores.

Sem dúvidas, faz pensar se todo mundo tem que criar o próximo Facebook para ser considerado um sucesso. Eu fortemente acredito que não.

Até amanhã!

Brainstorm9Post originalmente publicado no Brainstorm #9
Twitter | Facebook | Contato | Anuncie


Advertisement


What’s Your Favorite Female Ad Icon of All Time?


Ad Age wants to know which icon is tops with readers.

Eccentric Ladylike Editorials – Rose Smith is ‘Lady Fendi’ in Citizen K International Fall 2012 (GALLERY)

(TrendHunter.com) The masterminds behind the Citizen K International Fall 2012 editorial have dubbed model Rose Smith as ‘Lady Fendi.’ Although that isn’t an official title, it might as well be for…

Personal Workspace Portraits – Photographer Meggan Gould Explores the Places We Make Our Own (GALLERY)

(TrendHunter.com) Photographer Meggan Gould has put together a wonderful series of photographs entitled ‘Workspaces,’ that takes an intimate look into the rooms, offices and studios of various creative people….

Socialnomics, para não dizer que não falei das flores.

SMW

A primeira palestra do Social Media Week que eu encarei aqui em Chicago foi a do Erik Qualman, autor do celebrado Socialnomics. A palestra em si não apresentou nada exatamente novo. Ele trabalha com Mídias Sociais, eu e boa parte do povo que acompanha o B9 também. Acreditar que as pessoas e o que elas comentam e fazem circular pela Internet impacta diversos setores das empresas, que devem começar a ouvir e agir de acordo com estas manifestações faz parte do nosso dia-a-dia.

Como cheguei a comentar em um tweet, é batido demais mostrar o vídeo de apresentação deste livro em palestra. Mas como o livro é dele, tudo bem, né? Detalhe: mostrou uns 10 segundos e avisou que o resto estava no YouTube.

Outro com menos sucesso, mas bem mais engraçado, foi o produzido pela equipe de Qualman para exemplificar porque a garotada adora Mídias Sociais:

Ainda hoje, prometo, volto para falar de outras coisas bacanas que aconteceram ontem.

Brainstorm9Post originalmente publicado no Brainstorm #9
Twitter | Facebook | Contato | Anuncie


Advertisement


10-Step Guide to Social Link Building

Social media has become a powerful tool in attracting a large number of inbound links at a low cost. In this whitepaper, part of the Adrants Whitepaper Series, HubSpot provides ten steps for brands seeking to get others to link to their site without spending a red cent on advertising or other promotions. From guest blog posts to contests to lists to content distribution strategies and more, the whitepaper provides how to tips as well as real world examples of the tips in action.

Download the free whitepaper now to find out how you can put social link building and inbound marketing to work for your brand.


Why Deal Between NFL, Referees is Good News For Madison Avenue


Longer games didn't mean more ads, just outraged fans — which is bad for sponsor business.

Rewind: When the Church of Scientology Was a Master of Book Marketing


Before "The Master" and before Tom Cruise, there was "Dianetics."

When the Church of Scientology Was a Master of Book Marketing

Before 'The Master' and before Tom Cruise, there was 'Dianetics.'

Barbarian Group Delivers More GE Flyovers

CapturFiles-Sep-26-2012_01.23.13.jpg

Barbarian Group is out with some stellar new GE work that extends its recent work for the brand’s GE Flyover work which takes people inside factories where GE technology is used.

In this version, visitors can select from one of three locations for each mission. These locations feature technology GE has placed in action and the goal is to highlight the people and the machines behind GE. Selections will be then voted upon and the GE helicopter will head out on its mission.

The work acts on recent GE and Buzzfeed study findings that indicate shared creative content yields far greater results than simple online paid placements.


Coke FM ‘Magazine Dock’ Solves iPhone 5 Docking Problem

CapturFiles-Sep-26-2012_12.47.01.jpg

Very, very cool. To celebrate the one year anniversary of Coke FM, the brand’s online radio station, JWY Brazil turned an issue of Brazilian teen magazine Capricho into a speaker dock for an iPhone. With some simple die cuts, the agency turned the magazine into a lasting branded element. Well, at least for those who can’t afford a real iPhone dock.

With the new iPhone making every existing docking station obsolete, this iphone magazine dock may have a longer than expected lifespan


Duracell ‘Trust Your Power’ Tells Powerful Patrick Willis Story

CapturFiles-Sep-26-2012_12.33.49.jpg

Well if only batteries could actually achieve what San Francisco 49ers pro linebacker Patrick Willis achieved. Powerful new work from Saatchi & Saatchi NY, Trust Your Power, offers a moving portrait of Willis, the challenges he faced growing up and his drive to overcome them.

Narrated by Patrick, himself, the two minute video examines Willis’ life. In a voiceover, Will says, “Looking back on it…on how I got to where I am, I don’t know if it was because I was running towards something or whether I was running away from it. But that didn’t matter. What I did know is when you run into something something bigger, something meaner, something with the power to knock you down, you have to trust yourself, trust that you can get up and not give in. Ever. Because power isn’t just about going forward. It’s about not letting anything hold you back. You find that in yourself, you can go anywhere you want.”

It’s a very personal piece and one that’s interesting in its own right despite the fact it’s branded content. We’d like to see more brands adopt this approach. Not necessarily with pro athletes all the time. There are plenty of regular human beings out there who have their own very power stories of achievement to tell.

Nice work, Saatchi & Saatchi.


Do You Work for a Fee, or for Free?


Advertising pros need to fend off those asking to pick our brains for free.

Saint Michel – Katherine

Le duo versaillais Saint Michel a fait appel au réalisateur Louis De Caunes pour mettre en images leur morceau appelé Katherine. Produite par Paradoxal, cette vidéo met en scène les membres du groupe jouant en musique avec les lumières des immeubles de New York. A découvrir en images dans la suite.

Saint-Michel-Katherine7-640x264
Saint-Michel-Katherine6-640x264
Saint Michel - Katherine8
Saint Michel - Katherine7
Saint Michel - Katherine6
Saint Michel - Katherine4
Saint Michel - Katherine3
Saint Michel - Katherine2
Saint Michel - Katherine1

40 Circuit Board Reinventions – From Geeky Baked Confections to Circuit Board Neckties (TOPLIST)

(TrendHunter.com) These circuit board reinventions showcase the possibilities of up-cycling with hardware.

The usage of circuit board hardware can be used in unconventional ways to create art, clothing and even new…

Adidas cria campanha em torno da recuperação de Derrick Rose do Chicago Bulls

Quando Derrick Rose do Chicago Bulls, MVP de 2010/2011, se machucou na primeira partida dos playoffs da temporada 2012, não só os torcedores da equipe ficaram devastados, como também os fãs de basquete.

Desde o primeiro momento, a Adidas transformou o drama e a recuperação do jogador – que lesionou o joelho – em uma grande campanha, chamada “The Return”. Além de manter D Rose e seu contrato milionário na mídia, a iniciativa colecionou o apoio dos torcedores através de mensagens nas redes sociais.

No mais recente filme da campanha, a Adidas mostra o mundo em pausa durante o tratamento do jogador, gerando ainda mais expectativa pelo seu retorno. Apesar da excitante narrativa da marca, a verdade é que D Rose só deve mesmo voltar às quadras no ano que vem, o que não impede, claro, a promoção de uma nova linha de tênis assinada pelo armador do Chicago Bulls.

A criação é da 180LA.

Brainstorm9Post originalmente publicado no Brainstorm #9
Twitter | Facebook | Contato | Anuncie


Advertisement


85 Examples of Wild Wigs – These Halloween Wig Ideas Make for Spooky Fun (TOPLIST)

(TrendHunter.com) Draw inspiration from these Halloween wig ideas to take your costume to the next level of standout style.

Hair is a highly important part of a Halloween costume as it adds an another dimension of…

Alicia Keys está de volta. E pegando fogo.

No começo do mês, Alicia Keys divulgou o primeiro single de seu mais novo álbum, Girl On Fire, que chega só em novembro.

O interessante é que você pode escolher entre duas versões da música nova para ir entrando no clima do disco.

Existe a versão mais funkeada, mais dançante, e a versão light, para quem quiser ir chegando com calma nas novas aventuras musicais dessa vocalista e multi-instrumentista que conquistou o mundo há mais de 10 anos com sua mistura de neo-soul com R&B.

Enquanto o álbum novo não chega, você pode ouvir as duas versões de Girl On Fire abaixo, aproveitar para dar uma espiada nos bastidores da gravação do disco e ver uma performance da diva mostrando outra pérola de sua nova safra de pop de primeiríssima linha. Divirta-se!




Brainstorm9Post originalmente publicado no Brainstorm #9
Twitter | Facebook | Contato | Anuncie


Advertisement


Who Is That Hot Deutsch LA Girl?

CapturFiles-Sep-26-2012_10.17.07.jpg

Here’s a job (probably an easy one) for the guys over at Who Is That Hot Ad Girl. And this girl is an actual ad girl. As in one that makes ads, not just appears in them. This video is Deutsch LA’s entry into LA’s AdJam 2012 which takes place this Thursday at House of Blues.

In the video, entitled Helvetica, the agency rocks out to KISS’s I Wanna Rock and Roll All Night.