Super Sunday. Two Days Later

penn-state-football.jpg

penn-state-football.jpgThree days later, it’s interesting to look back at the Super Bowl spots, knowing how people (non-industry people, that is) and the press reacted to them.

The Coke balloon spot seems to be generating the most positive buzz, both because of the simple brilliance of the execution and the fact that Coke hasn’t done anything this memorable in a while. Something I particularly appreciated about the spot is that it’s appeal is fairly universal, e.g. everyone from grandparents to teenagers could appreciate it. This is the sort of thing I was talking about in “Not Everyone Is An Upscale Urban 30someting White Male Hipster” – commercials that transcend demographics. And while I realize that Coke (the brand) is supposed to transcend demographics and appeal to everyone, the spot is a brilliant example of how to do it right.

Bud and Bud Light also scored well and while there were no surprises there, the spots were true to the brand image(s) and yet managed to stay fresh. (Though I was surprised to read in The Wall Street Journal that one of the ad creatives actually cried at the Clydesdale spot—I thought it was sort of charmingly funny, rather than a tearjerker. Maybe she once had a Dalmatian?)

And then there’s GoDaddy.

Now I’m still not sure that there isn’t some sort of method to the madness: I never knew what they did until I had to register a domain name and GoDaddy’s name popped up. And given a choice between them and 3 companies I’d never heard of, I went with GoDaddy. Which may be the point of their advertising after all—creating name awareness for a product I won’t care about until I need it.

Or they might really like naked chicks.

The changing TV news environment

So what’s the relevance of wiener poopie?

Well, a bit of post-Super-Bowl-extravaganza humor never hurts. But more importantly, it speaks (albeit in a bizarre way) to the rapidly changing television environment. Every time I turn on the TV and flip through the cable news channels, I’m surprised. While I’d like to think CNN running a story about a Jesus statue being held hostage is just an anomaly, I’m quickly realizing that is no longer the case. Television is rapidly beginning to emulate much of the internet, and news channels are prime examples. Turning into more of an extravaganza-style, shows like Countdown with Keith Olberman and much of the general CNN and MSNBC’s newscasts showcase rapidfire bits and trinkets, with significantly less in-depth analysis. The local news in Portland has even begun pulling and featuring clips off of YouTube in their newscast and soliciting viewer photos and videos – taking user-generated beyond content and into the realm of factual news.

So the big question: what direction is television viewership moving? Programs are becoming more rapid-fire bits and pieces, emulating on-line news aggregators and video sites. Are the viewers themselves shifting as well? or are broadcast and cable tv just trying to figure out how to maintain their media share in the presence of the ever-growing internet community? Does that shift change the way viewers interact with the advertising alongside these newscasts? Either way, it’s interesting to watch as a viewer, and certainly could have some impact down the road in terms of advertising and branding on tv.

Technorati Tags: CNN, MSNBC, news, user-generated content, youtube, beyond madison avenue

Our Best Audience

watching_tv.jpg

So there’s this new website called Firebrand that a few of my friends have something to do with. And because the site does nothing but show commercials, they’ve been thinking I’d have an interest in it.

This is not AdCritic (Creativity-Online these days) mind you. Or even AdFreak or AdRants. The site is aimed at the general public and its founders believe that people really want to watch good ads. (Good being the operative word here.)

And while it surprises me at some level that people outside the business actually want to watch commercials, it probably shouldn’t. I mean who would have predicted Civil War re-enactors, right? Plus there’s that moment we’ve all been through, when some guy at a party finds out you work in advertising and starts asking you all about his favorite commercial, some local car dealer ad where the salesman gets a pie in the face and you have to (a) pretend you’ve seen it and (b) pretend you know the guys who did it. And for a brief moment there, despite the seeming awfulness of the premise, you’re shocked, completely shocked at how deeply this guy connects with this car dealer spot and you wonder if anyone’s ever connected that deeply with something you’ve done.

And it got me to thinking how jaded we all are to advertising and the role it plays in people’s lives. (Okay not all people’s lives, but certainly many. I’d even settle for some.) How ads really are little movies or posters that people enjoy over and over every time they see them because they know nothing of all the sweat and grief and 3 hour meetings with account people saying “calendared” that went into making them. They don’t notice that the logo is on the bottom left either, even when we all know it really should have been on the top right because they’re charmed by the previous 27 seconds and their brains know to tune out for the last 3.

Which is the catch, of course. These commercial addicts have probably never bought anything from any of the brands advertised in the ads they watch on Firebrand. Because the reason they love these commercials has nothing to do with the brands they’re advertising, but with the writing and casting and lighting and propping and wardrobe and camera speed and pacing and editing. You know, all that stuff we call “craft.”

And so while Firebrand’s audience may never turn out to be “brand evangelists” they may well turn out to be “advertising evangelists.”

These days, we sure could use some.

Mercedes-Benz SL History (:60)

As I recently viewed a new M-B commercial, I was reminded of this one that debuted about a year ago. I kind of liked this one better… so, I’ll discuss this SL History one I call “Timeless”.

This :60 spot featuring the convertible SL models over the decades successfully does more to celebrate the brand, position Mercedes-Benz as a premier, ritzy icon through the last half century than it does actually “Introducing the 5th Generation SL”. No matter…it works for me. I think most of us who dream of buying or leasing one of these 4-wheeled icons are actually purchasing the brand — both its history and its present.

Although I don’t think the execution of such an idea is all that challenging, I do think it was done well. The ad’s music is aspirational and not offensive to anyone… as it takes us for a ride from one decade to the next (in each of the 5 generation SL convertibles). We re-visit the people, the trends, the fashion (or lack there of), as we witness the timeless elegance of the M-B SL Convertible. The lines and balance of this car (regardless of which generation) never seem outdated — even today.

The car, the icon, and this ad make me agree with the partially tweaked tagline for Mercedes-Benz, “Timeless. Unlike any other.” Timeless, indeed.

Technorati Tags: , , , ,

The Water Horse makes a holographic splash in Japan

I’m fascinated with the way some movies are promoted, and severely disappointed with others. I’m becoming significantly less impressed with the “first trailers” showing a practically unintelligible glimpse of something, followed by only a string of numbers, often cryptically written so as to leave one confused, disgruntled, and generally disinterested (although that could just be me). Godzilla, Transformers, and Cloverfield all followed a similar hype-inducing pattern.

I applaud Columbia TriStar for jumping right out there and creating a giant water-hologram over Tokyo Bay to promote The Water Horse’s opening in Japan:

The projection technique is actually pretty well-suited for to movie, which earns them bonus points in my mind. It’s rare to see a flashy promo technique that truly fits with the message (or the water horse, as the case may be). Disney pioneered the water projection technique years ago in the show Fantasmic, and has continued to develop it in rides like Pirates of the Caribbean.

It’s interesting to see it being used outside of the traditional-and-expected theme park environment and to see the way movie promotions are shifting away from the screen. While The Water Horse may seem like an odd choice to promote at that level, it’s still a stunning display and an interesting application of the medium. Take that Cloverfield.

Technorati Tags: Movies, hologram, promotion, marketing, beyond madison avenue

Not Everyone Is An Upscale Urban 30Something, White Male Hipster

hipster2.jpg
If all the ads you see on television sound like they’ve been written by the same person, a slightly snarky, all-knowing hipster, odds are they have. Or, more accurately, by a crew of people who all strive to have the same voice: that of the creative directors who judge award shows.

And while the work that wins at these shows (especially the big ones) is generally great, it’s generally work that appeals far more to the upscale, urban, 30something white male hipsters who judge these shows than it does to say, your grandmother, who doesn’t get why those Burger King spots with the mask are the least bit funny.

Now this theory is fine when you’re advertising beer or running shoes. But since most products advertised aren’t beer or running shoes, we quickly find ourselves in trouble: we’re talking with one voice to an audience who speaks with another. And whether it’s TV, print or online (okay, especially online), the messages we’re putting out there are “we don’t really know you, our customers. We don’t really care what you think is cute or funny or emotional. We only care what’s cool and hip (by our standards) so get used to it.”

I’ve made it practice on my blog to call out ads that appeal to different demographics: A Canon camera spot with Maria Sharapova’s dog, for instance, that my kids find hilarious.

Now of course it’s not impossible to create advertising that appeals to a broad demographic. The Budweiser Frogs campaign from about 10 years ago did that, so does some of the better Coke and Pepsi advertising. But by and large, we’re advertising to a specific demographic. And I’ve yet to see a brief that says “here’s what the target’s taste level is. Here’s who they find funny, the TV shows they love to watch, the magazines they read.” And the award shows don’t help this situation: they often reward work that has no appeal to the intended target.

No wonder so few people actually like commercials.

An Apple Fanboy Documentary: MacHeads The Movie

Brands becoming more than just a brand is nothing new. Lifestyle brands have been changing the way consumers interact with product for years. Technology brands are continuing the trend at a rapid pace. Apple is developing product after product to cater to fans and platform-switchers alike. Zune brought us The Social. Our tech gadgets are beginning to orchestrate our lifestyles, and many are becoming truly dependent on technology. Today, everywhere we look, we see tech gadgets and their advertising.
Apple certainly doesn’t need any help making their presence felt any more this week with the release of the Macbook Air and their banner ads that have been making a very large presence on many website front pages. But companies with as many fans as Apple has seems to attract attention no matter what they do. Browsing through Gizmodo this morning, I ran across a trailer for an actual documentary in production: MacHeads. It’s bizarre, fascinating, and almost frightening. But it shows what can happen with a brand becomes much more than just a name and logo. And how the consumer mind can react when brands begin to transcend traditional messaging. I’m definitely curious to see what comes of MacHeads, and what it might mean for Apple.

Technorati Tags: Apple, computer, documentary, movie, beyond madison avenue

Let your fingers do the grinding.

Check out the latest concept in mobile gaming courtesy of Vans and the Miami Ad School. Leveraging the iPhone’s touch screen capabilities, Finger Fracture would allow you to control the skateboard in a way similar to finger boards. Different finger movements and combinations allow you to do different tricks. Brand integration is done seamlessly throughout. Select a shoe to pick a rider and their corresponding riding style. Then see how you rank on the worldwide ranking list. Very cool! So nice to see such a smart and engaging mix of branding and technology. Lets hope this concept makes it to launch.

Technorati Tags: , advertising, iphone, mobile, games,

Trannies, implants and toupees.

A light-hearted take at selling language lessons. Grey, Tel Aviv has fun focusing on the “dramatic difference” you’ll notice after only 2 weeks with the Berlitz Language School. It’s nice to see other countries having a little more fun and not being as uptight as us — even in more politically volatile locales. Then again, the language category has always been a little more experimental. But even the liberal sensibilities of overseas consumers can be offended by our ad brethren as evidenced in this banned Dutch ad for a language institute (Warning: not for the faint of heart!).Technorati Tags: , advertising, broadcast,

Hyundai Ad – “Commitment” (2007)

If you are one who believes capturing attention – and luring one to a special website – makes for a successful ad, then I think you’ll like this one from Hyundai. But, if you believe ads should directly help sell something and move people to want to purchase it NOW because of what they saw or heard, then this may not be your cup of tea.

I’ll try to explain…

I’ve watched this TV spot more than several times. It is odd and captivating…but, I’m not so sure it really sells the product (in this case, a brand and a car). But, it may move folks to type in Hyundai’s special, off-beat website ThinkAboutIt. And, I certainly have been thinking about it. And…I did do as the spot tells me, and checked out the website. So, I guess it worked on me. But, did it work for me and for Hyundai?

In all honesty, the spot engages me and makes me think a little — which is good. But, it doesn’t highlight the car well or tell me much — except the vehicle has a fine powertrain warranty (10 year/100,000 miles). So, am I more apt to go test drive and buy a Hyundai? I don’t know…probably not. But, it did make me go to its special website.

You tell me…is this a successful ad?

Technorati Tags: , ,

Social Media Is Only Social If You’re Alone

frustrated-computer-user-783217.jpg

As I mentioned in an earlier post, social networking sites like Facebook and Twitter would have made my teens and twenties a far more interesting time. These sites are ideal for the sort of audience whose social life is of paramount importance, whose lives revolve around their friends and going out, and who’d rather not be interacting with the people around them (e.g. their roommates and/or parents.)If indeed there are actually any people around them.

Add people—spouses and children, in particular—and suddenly the allure of constant Facebook updates dims. You’ve reached a different point in your life. One where social life takes a back seat and family life becomes your primary focus. Which is why the oft-repeated notion, that social media is going to take over our lives and become our primary means of interacting with the interweb strikes me as so completely naïve.

Now it’s no surprise that the majority of people promoting social networking sites as the Second Coming are, indeed, of an age where their social life is the focus of their existence. Many of them, I would guess, fall into yet a third category of social media user: the young professional careerist, someone working long hours, perhaps in an unfamiliar city or unfamiliar country, and a site like Facebook is their only social life

Now I realize that when you are young and single, it’s pretty hard to imagine a time when your life might be dramatically different. To wit, let’s look at one comment I received when I posted this same treatise on The Toad Stool:

In my view, Social Media gives you the opportunity to be scratch your socialization itch while letting you simultaneously ignore the dumbass sitting at the other end of your couch if you so choose.

The point being that the poster here could not imagine that “the dumbass sitting at the other end of your couch” might someday be his spouse or child. Someone he’d have no wish to actually ignore.

Which brings us back to my original point: social networking doesn’t work for a large portion of the population because if we’re socializing online, we’re being anti-social to the people we live with. And last time I checked, a goodly number of Americans lived in family units where the main focus of their social life was with other family members. Not members of their Facebook network.

Now this doesn’t mean we should discount the importance of social networking. For the aforementioned demos, it’s a huge part of their lives. But for people outside that demo, social networking will take on other, less all-encompassing forms.

Take LinkedIn, for instance. I love LinkedIn, as do many of my similarly-situated friends, because it allows us all to keep track of each other in a way that works with our lives. Most of my LinkedIn contacts are people I know through work. I like them all well enough, but they’re not social friends and so I don’t particularly care what music they’re listening to or what movies they enjoy. In fact, it would add an awkward stalkerish dimension to many of those relationships if I did.

What LinkedIn provides, however, is a socially acceptable way to get back in touch with people you’d lost touch with for no real reason. To maybe exchange an email or two and let each other know what you’ve been up to. It requires very little effort: I can check my LinkedIn account once or twice a week and be done with it, a fact I’ve found to be a potent sales tool when trying to convince friends to sign up.

Now that’s a social network that works for me. There are sure to be other sites developed that appeal to people who want even less involvement than that. And sites for people who want much, much more.

Social media is a wonderful innovation. But it’s far from a one-size-fits-all phenomenon. People (your customers) will cycle through various types of social media in the course of their lives, depending on what stage they are at and whether that stage is about external or internal socialization. (Because remember, it’s only “social” if you’re alone.) It’s something that gets swept under the rug in all the hoopla, but something that marketers need to keep top of mind if they want to succeed.

Chris Bosh-Generated Content

Chris Bosh plays basketball for the NBA’s Toronto Raptors (he’s a star forward.) But while he plays basketball in Canada, he’s originally from Texas. And this video, designed to get fans to vote for him in the All-Star Balloting, is an homage to the auto dealer commercials he saw while watching late-night TV back in the Lone Star State.

Bosh claims the spot cost him all of $20 (for the cowboy hat) and it’s admittedly hilarious- Bosh is a natural ham. And while I don’t usually approve of CGC (consumer generated content) I’m very happy to recommend this CGC (Chris Bosh-generated content.)

Props to him as well for having the insight to make this and post it on YouTube, where it’s already garnered close to 400,000 hits.

And now, no words from our sponsor.

It seems like only yesterday when Tivo first came on the market much to advertisers dismay. Marketers everywhere attacked the service, with the CEO of Turner going so far as to accuse commercial skippers of theft. A lot has changed since then. Advertisers have slowly come to terms with the fact that people will fast forward through ads and Tivo has introduced a new products in an attempt to appease these advertisers including pop-up banners and other more interactive units.

But even as this un-easy alliance has been forged, no one seems to be taking much notice of Apple TV. With the latest version now supporting not only a slew of popular tv shows but the ability to rent movies — and with both options being available in HD — I’m surprised we haven’t heard more screaming from marketers. Imagine if everyone started consuming all of their tv and movie entertainment in this a la carte style and the implications it would have not only for advertisers but cable providers as well. Let’s do the math. I’ll use my own television and movie consumption as an example. As someone employed in advertising I figure it’s my duty to watch tv, and I do enjoy a HD picture so I currently subscribe to DirecTV. My package includes some premium channels, the HD and the DVR options and currently runs me $101.97 a month. I also use Netflix which runs another $18.43. So a month of tv and movies costs me $120.40. The reality is I don’t watch that much tv and often don’t get through my 3 movies a month — who has that amount of time? Out of the zillions of channels I have I really only watch a handful of shows: 30 Rock, Lost, The Office, Project Runway, Top Chef and a few others that I’ll just refer to as guilty pleasures — so 7 shows in all a week or about 28 a month which is probably a little high since I never seem to catch them all. If I were to purchase those same programs through Apple TV I’m looking at $55.72. If I throw in 3 movies, which again is a little high, I’m looking at another $14.97 assuming I’m going with just new releases in HD. So for only $70.69 I can have access to all of the content I regularly watch (with much of it in higher quality HD) at a savings $49.31 a month and all without any advertising! Hmmmmm. Advertisers and cable providers need to prepare themselves as an increasing amount of different entertainment distribution models become available. TV spots, it’s been nice knowing you. Now back to your regularly scheduled program.

Technorati Tags: , advertising, broadcast,

Microsoft goes shopping

While Apple has been making a splash this week, tech-giant Microsoft has been busy with shopping carts. They have started a nine-month pilot program with MediaCart and Wakefern ShopRite stores to display point-of-purchase ads in 220 grocery stores in Connecticut, Delaware, New Jersey, New York, and Pennsylvania. While Microsoft doesn’t have the same web advertising presence as Google, Yahoo and other giants, they are rapidly expanding into emerging digital channels. Last year’s acquisition of aQuantive, Inc. puts them in a unique position to market via new digital channels.

Equally interesting will be the consumer reception to one more screen vying for their attention. Not to mention the cart’s abilities to check your location in the store via RFID, specifically target ads based on what items your near, and the ability to track your shopping habits. Highly effective from a p.o.p. view, and tentatively useful for understanding consumer habits and patterns, but if the consumer doesn’t befriend the machine perched at the end of the cart, results could be lackluster. Early responses to the idea from the public seem to be mixed, but the technology certainly has a good deal to offer, if utilized effectively. I’ll be curious to see how effectively (and creatively) Microsoft can handle the task of in-cart-advertising. If you’re curious about the carts, there’s a bizarrely mesmerizing video of the carts in action on the MediaCart website.

Technorati Tags: marketing, Microsoft, shopping cart, beyond madison avenue

Apple Does It Again

This video for the new Apple Macbook Air is everything an Apple video should be. Simple, nicely lit, well cast/costumed (”John” from the Apple store, a Steve Jobs lookalike in a logoless black long-sleeved tee, his salt’n’peppa hair gelled into a youthful “Ross.”)

It continues the whole Total Branding Experience that Apple’s famous for. No one else could have done that video, the whole feel is so Apple.

The underlying message? “Look how cool this machine is. Don’t you want one? Don’t you want to pay a little more for one?”

You know that you do too.

Kia Ad “All-New Rondo” (2007)

I’m a real sucker for clever music, nostalgic warm feel, and an ad that puts a smile on my face — WHILE still taking away some points of information about the product! Wow…what a concept! Good ads that entertain and inform!

This 2007 spot introducing the new crossover SUV Kia Rondo does all of that…and does it extremely well. The 1960’s music/feel singing “let the sun shine in” (complete with hippie-type waiving young people and a rainbow highlighting the Rondo as it moves through the commercial) makes you take notice and smile throughout the :30 spot. Hence, while you’re captivated by the music, you pay attention to what the commercial is trying to communicate.

The psychedelic theme permeates the spot with talking points such as “MPG Happiness” (29 MPG), “Huge Cabinocity” (comes with available 3rd row of seating), “Precision Steerology” (drives like a car), and comes with a solid 10 year/100,000 mile powertrain warranty. And to top off this :30 spot is the final frame welcoming us to “Rondoism” that starts at a price of only $16,995.

We are shown the car (inside and out), learned about some of its appealing attributes, set an attractive/affordable price, and made me smile. I think this spot really rang the bell…and didn’t take itself too seriously. I enjoyed it.

Technorati Tags: , ,

Twice the effort. Half the fun.

musicpassSo Sony has finally bitten the bullet and starting January 15, 2008 will be offering there music catalog DRM-free. Hooray! In an attempt to regain some market share from our good friends at Apple, the clever folks at Sony have finally ditched DRM on at least some of their catalog. Yes, not all, just some — 37 albums by artists including Carrie Underwood, Jennifer Lopez and I’m hoping at least 35 others. But it gets better. Never mind that they were the last of the major labels to do so. Nor the fact that you can already purchase DRM-free music on iTunes, all be it for a premium. What really sets Sony apart is their ingenious model. Yes now if you want to buy Sony music online, you first have to go to an off-line retailer, buy a “Platinum MusicPass” then go online and visit MusicPass.com, where you then enter the code from the back of your card and finally get your music. Voila! Online music shopping really couldn’t get an easier than that. Amazing. And I’m assuming that because they are just so confident that hordes of people are going to run to stores, and then run home to buy their music they are not really promoting the new offering at all. Guess they’re counting on all that great word-of-mouth they hope to get.

Technorati Tags: , , advertising,

The Escape Pod

click to expand

The Escape Pod, a new-ish agency and bright light in an otherwise lifeless Chicago ad market is running this self-promo ad in the March issue of Fast Company magazine, which features the “50 Fastest Companies”
Now just doing a self-promo is pretty smart, in and of itself– so few agencies remember that they need to market themselves every bit as much as they market their clients.

But I was equally as impressed with the media placement (a magazine aimed at forward thinking start-ups and businesspeople) and with the ad itself.Illustrated by Joe Simko, who’s done a lot of rock album artwork, the ad is less a mission statement than “a poster to explain our agency in a light way,” according to agency founder Vinnie Warren, he of “Wasssup!” fame.

Given the degree of seriousness which so many agencies take themselves these days, this attitude is quite refreshing. Hopefully the client base will feel the same way.

Out, damn’d spot!

clearasil

The world’s smallest ad?! Check out this clever use of print. Love it or hate it, it gets noticed just like the those pesky pimples it promises to vanquish. The latest work for Clearasil from Euro RSCG Düsseldorf, Germany uses a “specially created pimple sticker” to instantly turn the covers of popular youth magazines into Clearasil Ads. The back of the sticker drives to clearasil.com, and due to high demand they are producing more of the stickers to be used as giveaways. Yeah, I know I can’t wait to cover my Trapper Keeper in pimple stickers — so cool! Still, it’s a really smart use of media. Just wish they would have given a little more thought to the online experience. Once you get there, it’s just another generic product site. Why not replicate the print experience there? Let people upload photos, pimple-ize them and share them with friends? Seems like a huge missed opportunity — almost as big that pimple. How can you miss it?
Technorati Tags: , advertising,

The Thrill of Victory, sans the Agony of Defeat.

adidas
A really lovely spot for Adidas and the 2008 Beijing Olympics brought to you by the talented folks at Psyop & TBWAChina. The first of four spots, “Together” uses a combination of live action action and illustration to create very distinct look that is both clean and austere, while also being warm. A welcome respite from the traditional athlete montage pieces, this spot really conveys the emotion and power that is the Olympics. I don’t think they really needed to end on the full live motion footage, but hey, all-in-all really nice work. Read more about what went into it here.
Technorati Tags: , advertising, broadcast,